有机替代对砂姜黑土小麦季温室气体排放及净增温潜势的影响*

The Impact of Organic Substitution on Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Net Warming Potential in Winter Wheat Season of lime concretion black soil

  • 摘要: 有机替代以其较高的固碳增汇潜力一直是研究的热点,然而土壤类型、气候特点对于有机替代固碳降温效果影响较大,多高替代比例可以兼顾典型土壤区作物产量和减排效果还缺乏针对性研究。基于此,本研以砂姜黑土为研究对象,设置对照(CK)、纯化肥(OPT)及不同有机(鸡粪)替代(1/4M、1/2M、3/4M和M),开展两年土壤增汇试验,并在第二年监测小麦季两次施肥期温室气体(GHGs)排放。结果显示,砂姜黑土农田土壤有机碳随着有机替代比例的升高呈显著增加趋势,但固碳效率(SOCSR)有所下降;关键温室气体N2O排放随着替代量的增加呈现先增加后减少的趋势,尤其1/4M处理的N2O排放量最高,其次为OPT处理和1/2M处理,而CK和M处理的N2O排放量最低;CH4排放中除了1/4M处理最高外,其余处理差别不显著,并整体不高。综合GHGs和土壤固碳效率(SOCSR),发现高量有机替代的农田净增温潜势(field-GWP)为-4881.6 kg CO2_eq ha-1,显著低于其他处理,而1/2M处理的field-GWP最高,达到-1411.4 kg CO2_eq ha-1,显著高于其他处理(CK除外),field-GWP随着替代量的升高呈先增加后降低的趋势。此外,小麦基肥期N2O和CH4排放量显著高于追肥期,其中基肥期N2O排放占总排放量的59.1-67.3%,CH4排放占总排放量的61.9-75.0%。不同处理中1/2M处理小麦产量最高,其次为1/4M处理,再次为3/4M和OPT处理,而全替代(M)的产量最低。折中小麦产量和field-GWP,本研究认为50%鸡粪替代既可以维持砂姜黑土小麦产量,同时也可实现较明显的固碳减排效果,成为砂姜黑土麦田综合经济和生态效益的最佳替代比例。

     

    Abstract: The organic alternative, with its higher carbon sequestration and carbon sink potential, has always been a research hotspot. However, the soil type and climate characteristics have a significant impact on the carbon sequestration and cooling effects of the organic alternative. There is still a lack of targeted research on the optimal substitution ratio that can balance crop yield and emission reduction effects in typical soil areas. Based on this, this study took lime concretion black soil as the research object and set up control (CK), pure fertilizer (OPT), and different organic (chicken manure) substitution (1/4M, 1/2M, 3/4M, and M) experiments for two years of soil carbon sequestration. GHG emissions were monitored in the wheat season of the second year. The results showed that the soil organic carbon in the lime concretion black soil cropland increased significantly with the increase of the organic substitution ratio, but the carbon sequestration efficiency (SOCSR) decreased; the key greenhouse gas N2O emissions showed different trends, with an increase followed by a decrease as the substitution rate increased; especially the N2O emissions of the 1/4M treatment were the highest, followed by the OPT treatment and the 1/2M treatment, while the N2O emissions of the CK and M treatments were the lowest; except for the 1/4M treatment, the CH4 emissions of the other treatments were not significantly different. Combining the GHGs and soil carbon sequestration efficiency (SOCSR), the net greenhouse gas potential (field-GWP) of the high-organic-substitution cropland was - 4881.6 kg CO2_eq ha-1, which was significantly lower than the other treatments, while the field-GWP of the 1/2M treatment was the highest, reaching -1411.4 kg CO2_eq ha-1, which was significantly higher than the other treatments (excluding CK), and the field-GWP increased first and then decreased as the substitution rate increased. In different treatments, the emissions of N2O and CH4 from basal fertilization of wheat were significantly higher than those from topdressing fertilization, with N2O emissions accounting for 59.1-67.3% of the total emissions and CH4 emissions accounting for 61.9-75.0 % of the total emissions. Comparing the yields of different treatments, it was found that the yield of the 1/2M treatment was the highest, followed by the 1/4M treatment, then the 3/4M and OPT treatments, while the yield of the full replacement (M) treatment was the lowest. Considering the wheat yield and field-GWP, this study concludes that 50% chicken manure replacement can maintain wheat yield in lime concretion black soil while achieving a significant carbon sequestration and emission reduction effect, making it the optimal replacement ratio for the comprehensive economic and ecological benefits of wheat production in lime concretion black soil.
     

     

/

返回文章
返回